
The Library Media — Opinion · Editorial
There Will Be an Accounting for the Loss of Humanity
By Catalina Clarke
The video is twenty seconds long, and it does not need sound.
A federal officer in a vest marked POLICE ICE lunges at a woman on a wet sidewalk in Los Angeles, both arms extended. The next image is the woman herself: face-down on the concrete against the wall of the county jail, her hair over her face, a pink megaphone lying beside her on the ground. Then the officers walk toward the camera — unhurried, unbothered — and the clip ends.
That was November 13, outside the Twin Towers jail on Bauchet Street, where a local newsroom’s log had already documented agents targeting people for arrest in the days before. The woman’s name has not been reported. No agency has issued a statement. No major newsroom has covered it. More than 180,000 people watched her hit the ground, and the official record of the United States government says nothing at all.
Hold that silence in mind, because it is the same silence that surrounds two graves in Minneapolis.
Renee Nicole Macklin Good was thirty-seven years old, a poet and a mother of three. On January 7, during the federal surge into Minneapolis, an ICE officer named Jonathan Ross fired into her vehicle. She was pronounced dead at Hennepin County Medical Center; the medical examiner ruled her death a homicide. Within hours — before any investigation could possibly have been conducted — the Department of Homeland Security announced that she had committed “an act of domestic terrorism.” The Justice Department later concluded there was “no basis” for a civil rights investigation. At least six federal prosecutors resigned in protest. Minnesota’s own investigators were shut out, and when evidence-sharing finally began, it was cut off again in September — indefinitely. Her family filed suit in October. Officer Ross has not been charged with anything.
Alex Jeffrey Pretti was thirty-seven years old, an intensive-care nurse at the Minneapolis VA — a man whose work was keeping strangers alive. On January 24, he moved toward a protester who had been pushed to the ground, a phone in his hand. Two Border Patrol and CBP officers shot him. The video record, reviewed frame by frame by Reuters, the BBC, the Wall Street Journal and the Associated Press, shows an agent pulling Pretti’s legally carried handgun away roughly a second before the shots. The department said he had come to “massacre law enforcement.” Its own preliminary report to Congress did not claim he brandished the weapon at all. A civil rights investigation was opened in January; it has produced nothing public since. The two men who shot him were identified not by their agency, which has never confirmed their names, but by ProPublica, working from government records. Neither has been charged.
None of this was hidden. It happened on camera, in daylight, in American cities. And the people positioned to stop it — people who knew, in their own private judgment, that it was wrong — said nothing, because they believed loyalty to power was a kind of armor. Say nothing, offend no one, and nothing can happen to you.
On election night, the voters took the armor away. Both houses of Congress changed hands.
And the response from the department that gave us Minneapolis was a statement of intent: ICE is “not backing away or slowing down.” The daily arrest target, by reported accounts, went up. The architect of the policy was promoted to chief of staff. Ten days after the election, a woman lay face-down on the concrete in Los Angeles, and no one in authority has yet bothered to learn her name.
There is a word for harm done deliberately, by the powerful, without a flicker of remorse, while the machinery of the state is arranged to ensure no one answers for it. The word is not enforcement.
We are not a house that believes in vengeance. An accounting is not vengeance. An accounting is what a serious country does instead — and it has already begun. It began on election night, in the one proceeding no pardon can overturn, when the voters rendered the first verdict themselves. What remains is the slower work: names spoken correctly and in full. Records kept. Lawsuits carried forward. Subpoenas readied for January, when the new Congress is seated. Videos that cannot be unwatched, however many officials decline to watch them. A pardon, flourished on the way out the door, can forgive a crime. It cannot unwrite a record. It cannot unhold an election. It cannot resurrect the pretense that none of this was seen.
It was seen. It is being written down. There will be an accounting for the loss of humanity — not because anyone thirsts for one, but because a country that refuses to count what was done in its name has already decided what it is.
Catalina Clarke
Editor-in-Chief, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us
