
The Library Media — National & World · World Desk
Six Somali Judges Take Constitutional Dispute to East African Court After Ruling President’s Term Expired
By Maya Wilson
Six Somali Supreme Court judges, including the court’s ousted Chief Justice, have taken the country’s constitutional crisis to the East African Court of Justice, alleging government interference with judicial independence after a ruling that President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s mandate had expired.
The six judges filed a reference at the court in Arusha, Tanzania, on November 18, according to Somali Guardian’s reporting. The filing followed a November 5 decision by a five-judge panel of Somalia’s Supreme Court that rejected the application of constitutional amendments extending presidential and parliamentary terms to officials already in office.
Somali Guardian reported that the Supreme Court ruled President Mohamud’s four-year mandate expired on May 15, 2026, while the mandates of both houses of Parliament ended on April 14. The amendments, adopted in March, extended the terms from four years to five.
The court ordered political leaders to agree on an electoral framework within 30 days and hold elections within 90 days.
The same ruling declared null and void the President’s November 4 dismissal of Chief Justice Baashe Yusuf Ahmed. According to Somali Guardian, the judges said the President lacked constitutional authority to remove the Chief Justice unilaterally and had interfered with a pending case.
The aftermath of the decision intensified the dispute. Somali Guardian reported that government troops deployed around the Supreme Court building within hours of the ruling. The security details of the Chief Justice and the five judges who issued the decision were withdrawn despite acknowledged threats, and the judges were barred from travelling.
The six subsequently took shelter at the Mogadishu residence of former President Sharif Sheikh Ahmed. Baashe Yusuf Ahmed publicly said he no longer felt safe in the capital, stating that his security was threatened by the President whose term the court had ruled had expired.
The judges who filed the EACJ case are Baashe Yusuf Ahmed, Salah Sheikh Ibrahim Diblawe, Abdikadir Idiris Essa, Abubakar Ahmed Ali, Abdikafar Hussein Isak and Abdiaziz Mohamed Yusuf. Somali Guardian reported that the court gave the Somali government 45 days to respond.
The government disputes the Supreme Court’s position. According to Somali Guardian, the presidency maintains that the March constitutional amendments are essential reforms intended to move Somalia away from its clan-based indirect electoral system toward direct, one-person-one-vote elections. Officials argue that the changes strengthen state institutions and do not amount to an unlawful attempt to extend the government’s hold on power.
The government also defended Baashe Yusuf Ahmed’s removal, citing complaints from judges, judicial staff and legal professionals about the administration of justice. It appointed Ibrahim Idle Suleiman, a former Chief Justice and presidential legal adviser, as his replacement. The Attorney General’s office has rejected the Supreme Court’s ruling on the terms as having no legal effect, Somali Guardian reported.
The judges’ case places the dispute before a regional court with authority to examine whether a member state has violated the East African Community Treaty. Somalia joined the East African Community as a full Partner State in 2024.
Somali Guardian reported that the judges’ reference concerns alleged interference with judicial independence and invokes Treaty principles of democracy, the rule of law, good governance and accountability under Articles 6 and 7.
The EACJ is not a general appeals court for Somalia’s domestic constitutional decisions. Its task in this case is to determine whether the government’s actions breached Community law, rather than to serve as an appellate court reviewing the Supreme Court’s interpretation of Somalia’s Constitution.
The 45-day response period gives the Somali government an opportunity to present its position. If it does not respond within that period, the EACJ can proceed to determine the case in its absence.
No EACJ ruling has been issued. The filing does not establish whether elections will take place within the timetable set by the Somali Supreme Court, and the dispute remains unresolved.
Maya Wilson
World Desk — The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us
