Poland’s Supreme Court Backs President in Dispute Over Constitutional Tribunal

Photo: Magdalena Bielecka / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

The Library Media — World

Poland’s Supreme Court Backs President in Dispute Over Constitutional Tribunal

By Maya Wilson, World Desk Lead

Share

Published November 19, 2026 · 3:06 AM PT

Photo: Magdalena Bielecka / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Poland’s Supreme Court has issued a resolution rejecting key elements of the government’s position on the Constitutional Tribunal, ruling that valid Tribunal decisions take effect even if they are not published by the government and backing the view that newly elected Tribunal judges must take their oaths in the president’s presence. The resolution, issued on Wednesday, aligns with the position of opposition-aligned President Karol Nawrocki, according to Notes from Poland.

The Supreme Court held that the government’s refusal to publish a Constitutional Tribunal ruling cannot prevent it from becoming universally binding. This rejects the government’s argument that such rulings take effect only after publication in the official Journal of Laws. Supreme Court judge Aleksander Stępkowski, quoted by Dziennik Gazeta Prawna, said that failure by the body responsible for publication could not allow executive abuses to undermine the binding force of Tribunal rulings. The former Law and Justice (PiS) government took the same position in 2016, refusing to publish rulings that contradicted its judicial policies.

The Supreme Court also held that a valid Tribunal ruling can be issued only by judges who, after being elected by parliament, have taken an oath before the president in his presence. That position supports Nawrocki and Tribunal chief justice Bogdan Święczkowski, who argue that judges cannot take their seats until the president receives their oaths in person. Parliament’s government-backed majority has selected eight new Tribunal judges this year, who would form a majority on the 15-member body. Nawrocki has refused to receive the oaths of five, citing concerns about their appointments or qualifications. Those judges instead held their own swearing-in ceremonies before a notary and sent their oaths to the presidential chancellery. They and the government argue that this fulfils the requirement for taking office.

The resolution itself is contested. It was issued by Supreme Court judges appointed through the National Council of the Judiciary (KRS) after its overhaul under the PiS government. Polish and European court rulings have found that the changes brought the council under political control and rendered it invalid. The current government generally rejects decisions involving judges appointed through the reformed KRS, whom it calls “neo-judges”. Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek wrote on Thursday that “the neo-judges in the Supreme Court have adopted a so-called resolution” and described any decision involving even one person appointed through the politicised KRS after 2017 as a “non-existent judgement”. He argued that the resolution was therefore invalid.

The dispute comes amid a wider crisis over control of the Constitutional Tribunal. Since March 2024, the government coalition led by Prime Minister Donald Tusk has refused to publish any of the 85 rulings issued by the Tribunal, arguing that three judges were unlawfully appointed under the previous PiS government. At the end of October, the eight new judges selected by parliament took control of the Tribunal and announced that Święczkowski had been suspended for failing to fulfil his duties. He, backed by Nawrocki and Supreme Court chief justice Zbigniew Kapiński, rejected the move as an illegal “coup d’état” and maintains that he remains in charge. Police have prevented him from entering the building.

On Wednesday, as the Supreme Court issued its resolution, the eight government-backed Tribunal judges announced that they had lifted Święczkowski’s immunity from prosecution at Żurek’s request. No next steps, enforcement mechanism or timetable following the Supreme Court resolution were reported.

Maya Wilson
World Desk Lead, The Library Media

From The Library — the estate of our family.

Follow Us

X Facebook Instagram Threads Mastodon Bluesky

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top