
The Library Media — National & World · World Desk
By Maya Wilson
The Philippine Supreme Court has declared unconstitutional a requirement that Filipino seafarers post a bond before enforcing monetary awards and damages won in labor cases, ruling that the provision imposed an unequal financial burden on workers seeking to collect judgments in their favour.
Photo: Photo: The Supreme Court of the Philippines, Taft Avenue, Manila (Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)
The decision, reported by The Philippine Star, invalidates the bond requirement under Section 59 of Republic Act 12021, the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers. The provision required seafarers seeking to execute monetary awards and damages to post a bond “to ensure restitution should the award be subsequently reversed or modified.”
The Court held that the requirement violated the Constitution’s Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses. It said the provision placed an additional financial obstacle before seafarers seeking to enforce favourable labour judgments, while subjecting them to a disadvantage not similarly imposed on other workers.
The ruling also voided related Department of Labor and Employment orders enforcing the bond requirement and Department of Migrant Workers orders concerning the use of its Agarang Kalinga at Saklolo Para sa mga OFW na Nangangailangan (AKSYON) fund to pay bond premiums.
The Court further declared Section 1, Rule XXII of the law’s implementing rules and regulations ultra vires and void. It found that the provision contravened the Magna Carta’s protection of rights, privileges and benefits Filipino seafarers had enjoyed before the law took effect.
The decision went beyond the bond requirement. The justices also declared unconstitutional Section 60 of Republic Act 12021 and Section 4 of Republic Act 10706, the Seafarers Protection Act, which set rules governing lawyers’ representation of seafarers in related cases.
Those provisions included a 10 percent ceiling on legal fees, requirements for notarized certifications and undertakings, and rules governing the collection of fees from seafarers.
The Court acknowledged that Congress could act against ambulance chasing and abusive practices. However, it held that authority over the professional conduct of lawyers and the practice of law belongs exclusively to the Supreme Court. The challenged provisions therefore exceeded the legislature’s authority in that area.
The justices did not strike down the Magna Carta in its entirety. The Court upheld provisions concerning maritime education and training, including the Maritime Industry Authority’s authority to establish standards for the quality of maritime education and seafarer competency.
It also sustained requirements concerning enrolment and opportunities for shipboard training, finding them reasonable. The prohibition on third-party providers charging tuition or matriculation fees for shipboard training was likewise upheld.
The decision was penned by Associate Justice Maria Filomena Singh and resolved five consolidated petitions challenging the Magna Carta. The petitions were brought by seafarers, labour organizations and maritime educational institutions. The petitioners were not identified in The Philippine Star’s report.
The ruling drew a welcome from Senator Risa Hontiveros, who had opposed the bond requirement during Senate deliberations on the legislation. In a reaction reported by the Inquirer, she said the decision removed a financial burden from seafarers who had already secured favourable judgments.
“We welcome the Supreme Court’s decision declaring the bond requirement under the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers unconstitutional. Finally, the burden has been lifted,” Hontiveros said.
She questioned why workers who had already won their cases should have to find additional money before receiving the awards owed to them.
“I can’t imagine that seafarers who have already won their case will still be asked to post a bond before receiving the money they deserve. They already lack money to buy medicine. Where would they get the money for a bond?” she said.
Addressing the seafarers who challenged the requirement, Hontiveros added: “this is your victory.”
The decision preserves the Magna Carta’s maritime education and training framework while removing provisions the Court found unconstitutional, including the bond requirement and legislative restrictions on the legal profession.
Maya Wilson
World Desk Lead, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us
