
The Library Media — World
New Zealand High Court Finds Pay Equity Law Changes Discriminated Against Women
By Maya Wilson, World Desk Lead
Photo: Tom Ackroyd / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
WELLINGTON, New Zealand — New Zealand’s High Court has ruled that changes made by the coalition government to the country’s pay equity law discriminated against women, finding the 2025 amendments inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act.
Justice Paul Radich issued a formal declaration of inconsistency on Thursday, November 19, finding that women working in undervalued, female-dominated occupations had been subjected to “unjustified discrimination” because of their sex.
“The undervaluation of jobs dominated by female employees is discrimination,” Radich wrote. He said the women affected “deserve to have the importance of the right, and the fact of its breach, recognised by the Court.”
The case was brought by five unions, including the Public Service Association (PSA), challenging amendments to the Equal Pay Act passed under urgency in May 2025. The changes were introduced by Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden and cancelled pay equity claims covering 33 workforces. The unions say more than 150,000 women lost claims through the changes.
Radich found that the government’s stated rationale for the legislative reset was not supported by evidence that it would improve the system. “The reason for the ‘reset’ was strictly financial,” he wrote. He found the previous system had been working as intended and that the government had provided “nothing tangible” to demonstrate that the amendments would make it better.
The judge also found that ministers could have pursued more proportionate measures, including allowing claims already under way to continue, rather than cancelling them.
The amendments were changed within two days of being announced and passed ahead of the 2025 Budget. According to figures reported by Stuff, the changes saved the government NZ$12.8 billion in potential increased wage costs over the following four years.
Evidence at the hearing also raised questions about the government’s public explanation for the reset. Nic Blakeley, chief executive of the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment, conceded under cross-examination that he had repeated ministers’ claims that the changes would improve the system’s robustness, although that was not his own personal view of the reforms’ objective.
The government’s case was defended by former solicitor-general Una Jagose KC, who argued that the amended law continued to help women and left avenues for pay equity claims open.
PSA national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons welcomed the judgment as a “groundbreaking historic decision”. She accused the government of having “cynically cancelled pay equity claims under the cover of darkness, without warning and without due democratic process”, describing the changes as “an immoral and now an unlawful betrayal and wage theft, plain and simple.”
Fitzsimons called on the next government to restore the original pay equity regime without delay. She also pressed the Opportunity Party, which campaigned on restoring pay equity to its 2020 settings, to make the issue part of any coalition negotiations. “No coalition deal should leave this egregious law on the books,” she said.
The political question is unresolved. Provisional election results give National, ACT and New Zealand First a narrow majority, but the final count could leave the parties reliant on support from the Opportunity Party during coalition negotiations. The party did not make restoration of the earlier pay equity settings a bottom line in its campaign.
The ruling does not repeal the amendments or automatically restore the cancelled claims. Instead, the declaration triggers a parliamentary review and requires a formal response from the next Attorney-General, which MPs will debate. The Crown retains the option of appealing the decision and was ordered to pay the costs of the hearing.
The unions did not succeed on every ground. The court rejected their argument that the government breached their rights by failing to consult them before introducing the bill, finding there was no legal requirement to consult.
Van Velden has been approached for comment. Neither report carried a substantive government response to the judgment.
Maya Wilson
World Desk Lead, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us
