The Library Media — National & World · National Desk
By Gideon Black
Benjamin Netanyahu is losing the procedural fight to remain in power. On Tuesday, November 17, his allies failed to prevent the election of a new Knesset speaker from the party that finished first in Israel’s October election. Hours later, the Central Elections Committee announced that a Shin Bet investigation had found no evidence of voter bribery on a scale capable of changing the result.
Neither development, by itself, ends Netanyahu’s political career or completes the formation of a new government. Together, however, they weaken two important parts of his position: his bloc’s ability to control the legislature during government negotiations, and his public allegation that the election was stolen through misconduct in the Arab community.
The man positioned to benefit is Gadi Eisenkot, whose centre-right Yashar party finished first on October 27. Eisenkot holds President Isaac Herzog’s mandate to form a government. Netanyahu remains caretaker prime minister, but his Likud party finished second and Eisenkot’s bloc is now making its authority felt inside parliament.
The Knesset, sworn in on November 10, voted 66–52 on Tuesday to elect Matan Kahana of Yashar as speaker, according to Times of Israel live coverage and France 24/AFP. The vote followed a six-hour filibuster by Netanyahu’s bloc, whose members had sought to delay the decision.
Kahana, 45, a former air force pilot, said in his first remarks as speaker that the next government would respect court rulings and work for the good of all Israelis.
The result is more than a change of parliamentary officeholder. The speaker has influence over the legislative agenda, and Kahana’s election gives the Eisenkot bloc control of that agenda while government formation continues. France 24 described the vote as a blow to Netanyahu, whose Likud finished second and who has been fighting to stay in office.
That matters because Eisenkot does not yet have a majority. Yashar’s bloc cannot govern alone, and he must negotiate agreements with other parties to assemble a coalition. Winning the speaker’s chair does not resolve those negotiations. It does, however, give the bloc holding the mandate a stronger procedural position while those talks proceed.
The second development goes directly to Netanyahu’s challenge to the election result.
Netanyahu has claimed that Arab parties stole the election through bribery, intimidation and forgery. His allegations followed record turnout among Arab voters, which deprived his bloc of its majority. On Tuesday evening, the Central Elections Committee said the Shin Bet investigation into alleged vote-buying in the Arab community had found no evidence of bribes paid on a scale that could affect the election result.
The committee’s statement was carefully qualified. It said: “Examination of the evidentiary and intelligence picture raises numerous suspicions, although at this stage there is no evidence of election bribes being paid to voters on a scale that could affect the election results.”
The statement was authorized by Central Elections Committee Chairman Noam Sohlberg, who is also deputy president of the Supreme Court, and issued with the consent of Shin Bet chief David Zini, according to the Times of Israel.
The distinction between suspicion and proof is central. The committee did not say that every allegation was fabricated or that no wrongdoing could have occurred. It said investigators had not found evidence of bribery on a scale that could have affected the election. The investigation is continuing, but its focus is shifting toward security-related questions involving subversion and foreign influence. The committee said those matters were not at the core of the electoral process and its results.
That finding substantially undercuts the central public claim that the election outcome was stolen through mass vote-buying. It does not erase every question investigators may still pursue, but it leaves Netanyahu without the evidentiary support necessary to establish that the alleged bribery changed who won.
The fate of the arrests also complicates the political case. The three Ra’am activists arrested on election day over the alleged vote-buying scheme have all been released. The case now appears likely to close without charges, according to the reporting.
The origin of the tip that led to the arrests is itself politically consequential. Channel 12 reported that it came from Daniel Greenberg, a former employee of the Prime Minister’s Office, and was passed through Netanyahu’s chief of staff, Ido Norden, one day before the election. The complaint that led to the arrests originated from Netanyahu’s office, according to the reporting.
The Times of Israel also reported that a court has given Likud more time to appeal the election results over its claims concerning Arab votes. That legal avenue remains open; the additional time is not a ruling in Likud’s favour and does not establish the allegations.
Earlier this week, officials in Eisenkot’s bloc said the election-day arrests affair had eliminated any chance of a unity government. They called it “no less than an attempted coup.” That is the bloc’s characterization, not an established legal finding. But politically, it signals how sharply the relationship has deteriorated: the party seeking to form the next government is no longer treating a unity arrangement with Netanyahu as a realistic route forward.
The combination leaves Netanyahu with fewer options. He has lost the speaker’s contest. The investigation has not substantiated the scale of election bribery required to overturn the result. And the arrests have become a source of further distrust between his camp and the bloc trying to replace him.
Eisenkot, meanwhile, has the presidential mandate and now the advantage of a speaker from his party. He still has to build a majority through negotiations, and Tuesday’s votes do not guarantee that he will succeed.
But the balance of the transition is becoming clearer. Netanyahu remains prime minister in a caretaker capacity, yet the institutions and negotiations that will determine the next government are increasingly moving beyond his control. His fight to stay in office is no longer simply a contest over political claims. It is a contest over who controls the parliamentary process—and Tuesday brought another important part of that process into Eisenkot’s hands.
Gideon Black, National Desk, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us
