Justice Department Halted Criminal Probe Into Senator Jim Justice’s Coal Businesses After Lawyer’s Intervention, MS NOW Reports

Portrait of Maya Wilson

The Library Media — National & World · National Desk

Justice Department Halted Criminal Probe Into Senator Jim Justice’s Coal Businesses After Lawyer’s Intervention, MS NOW Reports

By Maya Wilson

Share

Published November 21, 2026 · 12:12 PM PT · Updated November 21, 2026 · 12:22 PM PT

The Justice Department’s criminal investigation into allegations that companies owned by Republican Sen. Jim Justice of West Virginia falsified water-pollution test results was shut down in February 2026 after a lawyer for the businesses contacted the office of then-Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche, according to a six-month investigation by MS NOW.

The news organization reported November 19 that Blanche’s deputies subsequently directed supervisors in the department’s environmental crimes section to withdraw subpoenas seeking company records and water-test results, and to close the criminal inquiry. The intervention came while prosecutors were awaiting a judge’s decision on the company’s effort to block a records subpoena on attorney-client privilege grounds.

The Justice Department disputes that account. In an email to MS NOW, the department said it “did not shutter any investigation.” DOJ representatives and Southern Coal both maintained that there was insufficient evidence to pursue a criminal case.

The investigation began after prosecutors learned in late 2024 that two former employees said they had information indicating Southern Coal or sister companies were falsifying laboratory results used to determine whether mining operations were complying with pollution limits. The allegations, reported by MS NOW through two people familiar with the case who spoke anonymously, have not been proven. No one has been charged.

In February 2025, prosecutors opened a criminal investigation, concerned that company officials might be deliberately violating the law and the terms of a 2016 settlement with the Justice Department. The work was assigned to the environmental crimes section of the department’s Environment and Natural Resources Division.

Prosecutors later issued subpoenas for internal company records, approved by the office of Assistant Attorney General Stanley Woodward. A second set sought the water-test results. Southern Coal challenged the records request in court, arguing that the material was protected by attorney-client privilege.

In February 2026, James McDonald, a Sullivan & Cromwell attorney representing Southern Coal, contacted Blanche’s office to object to the investigation, MS NOW reported. McDonald and Blanche had both previously served as personal lawyers defending Donald Trump in the New York hush-money case. Sullivan & Cromwell did not respond to MS NOW’s request for comment.

An attorney for the Justice family told the news organization that the family had maintained a professional relationship with the law firm for nearly 20 years, unrelated to Trump.

Steven Ruby, a lawyer for the senator’s family businesses, said the companies believed the allegations originated with disgruntled former employees. He said the businesses provided the Justice Department with evidence refuting the claims and that prosecutors then found no basis to continue investigating.

A DOJ spokesperson said the department takes seriously its responsibility to ensure Americans have clean air and water and works with investigating agencies to follow the facts.

Sen. Justice, questioned outside his Capitol Hill office, directed questions about Southern Coal to his son, who runs the business. He denied that water tests had been falsified, calling the allegation “bogus as bogus can be” and saying there was “no chance whatsoever” that the companies were involved in such conduct. He said the family business would not harm West Virginians and declined to answer further questions.

The companies are part of a mining conglomerate owned by Justice and largely run by his son, whom MS NOW did not name. The 2016 settlement followed more than 23,000 alleged pollution violations across five states. Southern Coal avoided a potential maximum of $880 million in fines by agreeing to pay $900,000, upgrade pollution controls and comply with the law.

Over the next six years, the government repeatedly returned to court alleging violations of that settlement. The disputes included unpaid penalties, a missed deadline for pollution-control upgrades in Tennessee, expired discharge permits and improper reporting of pollution entering waterways. The company argued that the consent decree did not explicitly require permit renewals. A federal appeals court rejected that position, describing it as an absurdity and an attempt to circumvent the law.

The consequences of water pollution remain a central concern for residents of Wyoming County, West Virginia, whom MS NOW interviewed. Residents told the news organization they could not safely drink or bathe in their tap water. They said independent tests had found heavy metals, including lead, arsenic and manganese, at levels sometimes 10 or even 100 times higher than EPA safe levels.

Residents and family members have received diagnoses including cancer, liver failure and thyroid dysfunction, according to the report. Some households said they were spending hundreds of dollars each week on water. Pansy Keene said she has third-stage kidney failure, which she attributes to the water. Community advocate Richard Altizer showed MS NOW creeks and rivers discolored orange, white and black by suspected mine contamination. He said residents had been relying on the federal investigation as their only hope. West Virginia pediatrician Kate Waldeck told the news organization she advises parents not to use tap water to prepare infant formula.

MS NOW also emphasized a critical limit to what can be concluded: without the investigation, neither the government nor the public can determine whether the Justice companies or another operator in the area is responsible for the contaminated water.

Former U.S. Attorney Rick Mountcastle, whose office helped bring the earlier civil case, called the reported shutdown “unheard of” and said it was troubling for a case to be stopped before an investigation was close to completion. Former Justice Department officials told MS NOW that the intervention by senior political appointees departed sharply from normal departmental practice.

The reporting also placed the case within a wider decline in environmental enforcement. Cases brought by the division fell to less than one-third of the previous year’s level, while civil penalties dropped from $1.88 billion in 2024 to $15 million in 2025. Renamed the Energy and Natural Resources Division in September, the division had lost nearly half its staff since January 2025. Former ENRD attorney Laura Thoms described the result as “open season for polluters.”

ProPublica and Mountain State Spotlight first reported in June 2026 that Justice Department leadership had ended the criminal investigation. At the time, DOJ told ProPublica the probe was a politically motivated prosecution inconsistent with the administration’s priorities. MS NOW’s reporting adds the account of the former employees who raised the water-testing allegations and the intervention by McDonald and Blanche’s office.

The central questions remain unresolved: whether the allegations of falsified tests were ever fully examined, and who is responsible for the contaminated water reported by Wyoming County residents. The available reporting does not establish that the Justice companies falsified results or caused the contamination.

Maya Wilson

World Desk Lead, The Library Media

From The Library — the estate of our family.

Follow Us

X Facebook Instagram Threads Mastodon Bluesky

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top