
The Library Media — World
ICJ to Deliver Landmark Myanmar Genocide Verdict on Thursday in Rohingya Case
By Maya Wilson, World Desk
THE HAGUE, Netherlands — The International Court of Justice will deliver its verdict on Thursday in a landmark case brought by The Gambia accusing Myanmar of committing genocide against the Rohingya, a ruling that could establish whether a state can be held legally responsible for genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention.
The case, The Gambia v. Myanmar, was filed in November 2019 with backing from the Organization of Islamic Co-operation. The Gambia argues that all states party to the convention have an obligation to uphold it and therefore have standing to bring a case, even when they are not directly affected. Myanmar challenged The Gambia’s right to do so, but the court ruled that it was eligible to file the case.
The judges must now decide whether Myanmar, as a state, committed genocide during the military operation in August and September 2017 that drove the Rohingya population from Rakhine State.
The BBC’s reporting describes that operation as one of exceptional brutality. Villages were deliberately burned, while human rights groups and a United Nations fact-finding mission documented accounts of killings, torture and mass rape by Burmese soldiers. Hundreds of thousands of Rohingya fled to neighboring Bangladesh, where more than a million remain in camps.
A 2018 UN report, based on hundreds of interviews, described the army’s tactics as “grossly disproportionate to actual security threats” and said senior Myanmar military figures should be investigated for genocide. Myanmar rejected the report.
Thursday’s verdict carries historic significance. Since the Genocide Convention was signed in 1948, individuals have been prosecuted for genocide in cases involving Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia. But no state has ever been found by an international court to have committed genocide.
The legal threshold is high. Unless there is an explicitly genocidal program, judges must conclude that genocidal intent is the only reasonable inference from the evidence.
The precedent most closely watched is the case brought by Bosnia-Herzegovina against Serbia. The ICJ found that the 1995 Srebrenica massacre constituted genocide, but ruled that there was insufficient proof that Serbia itself had genocidal intent. Serbia was instead found to have failed to prevent genocide.
The Gambia’s legal team has argued that the 2017 operation cannot be understood in isolation from decades of discrimination against the Rohingya. It presented the 1982 citizenship law and restrictions on education, healthcare, livelihoods and travel as evidence of an underlying intent behind what Myanmar called its military “clearance operations”.
Arsalan Suleman, The Gambia’s lawyer leading the case, told the BBC: “It would be a judgment of landmark importance if The Gambia were to win this case. It would give renewed vitality to the 1948 Genocide Convention and to the notion of international legal accountability for crimes committed by a state.”
Myanmar denies that it committed genocide or carried out ethnic cleansing. It says its forces were responding to terrorist actions by Rohingya militants. Aung San Suu Kyi, who then headed the elected government, personally led the initial defense at The Hague. She argued that The Gambia had mischaracterized a complex conflict, and that possible war crimes did not establish genocidal intent.
Aung San Suu Kyi was deposed in the 2021 coup and is under arrest. The defense is now led by a team appointed by the military. Min Aung Hlaing, the general who now runs Myanmar, was responsible for the military’s 2017 operations.
For Rohingya refugees, the proceedings have also carried the significance of public recognition. Mohammed Nowkim, who was driven from Buthidaung in 2017 and now lives in Canada, told the BBC: “This is like formal recognition of our suffering.” He added: “For the Rohingya, this trial is a moment of acknowledgement of our suffering after years of denial.”
The verdict will have legal weight but limited immediate enforcement consequences. There is no right of appeal against an ICJ verdict, and no penalty automatically follows one. Myanmar was not a signatory to the International Criminal Court, preventing a case there against the officials accused and helping explain why The Gambia pursued the ICJ route.
Even a ruling in The Gambia’s favor would not itself bring Rohingya refugees home. The Arakan Army now controls most of Rakhine State, many Rohingya villages have been destroyed, and international support has faded.
The court is due to read its verdict on Thursday, November 19. Until then, the question of whether Myanmar committed genocide remains before the judges.
Maya Wilson
World Desk Lead, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us
