
The Library Media — National & World · National Desk
ICE Recruiting Video Promising a Return to “The Way It Was” Draws Backlash Across the Spectrum
By Eleanor Ever Loyal
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement posted a one-minute recruiting video on its X account on Thursday, November 12, with the caption: “The way it was. The way it can be again.”
The video ends by directing viewers to join.ice.gov, the agency’s hiring site.
Watch the video and judge for yourself: it is posted on ICE’s official X account, @ICEgov.
The advertisement is built as a montage of vintage color and black-and-white images evoking mid-20th-century Americana. Its footage includes automobiles from the 1930s, roadside motels, a Texaco gas station, downtown streets, the Golden Gate Bridge, Mount Rushmore, a woman drinking a Coca-Cola, a couple laughing by the water and a mother pushing a stroller.
A female vocalist sings a nostalgic folk-style song over the images.
Raw Story and Mediaite, which reviewed the video, reported that every person whose face can be made out in the footage is white. That feature of the video, combined with ICE’s caption promising a return to “the way it was,” prompted criticism from commentators across the political spectrum.
Richard Hanania wrote on X: “We get immune to this but we need to keep pointing out that the people tasked with enforcing immigration law keep fantasizing about an all-white depopulated country.”
New York Times columnist David French wrote on X: “Oh I get it. It’s the whiteness. That’s what they want.”
Democratic strategist Maria Cardona described the video in a post on X as “one of the most offensive, racist, xenophobic, dog whistle for white nationalists propaganda I have ever seen coming out of an official US government account!”
Immigration lawyer Aaron Reichlin-Melnick described the message as nostalgia for an era that included Jim Crow. Alyssa Farah Griffin, who served in the first Trump administration, also questioned the advertisement, arguing that millions of Americans and Republican voters are descendants of nonwhite immigrants.
The reactions reflected differing political backgrounds, but shared criticism of the imagery and the racial meaning they said it conveyed.
Neither ICE nor the Department of Homeland Security, its parent agency, had publicly responded to the criticism as of Friday, November 13. No response had been reported in coverage of the backlash through the weekend.
The video appeared as ICE continued a broader effort to recruit new personnel. Stephen Miller had championed the ICE hiring drive before his promotion to White House chief of staff. President Trump selected Miller to replace Susie Wiles, and Miller took over the position on Monday, November 9.
The Washington Post has reported that ICE’s recruitment effort is expansive, with the agency seeking applicants through advertising and online outreach.
The new appeal also follows a Department of Homeland Security recruiting campaign in 2025 that made similar appeals. Critics said some material from that earlier campaign echoed white nationalist material.
ICE’s November video does not state in its caption or its closing recruitment message what period of American history it is asking viewers to remember or restore. The footage itself ranges across decades, from imagery associated with the 1930s through the 1960s.
What ICE intended the video to communicate, however, remains a matter of interpretation. The reporting contains no publicly verified evidence that the agency produced the advertisement to celebrate segregation or to advocate reviving Jim Crow laws.
The periods the footage evokes were also eras in which racial segregation was enforced by law in much of the United States. That historical fact is the ground on which the video’s critics have based their interpretation of its all-white imagery and its promise that “the way it was” could return.
ICE has not publicly offered an alternative explanation for the video’s meaning. Until it does, the criticism remains the critics’ interpretation of an official recruiting message, while the agency’s intent has not been publicly established.
Eleanor Ever Loyal
National Desk, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us
