
The Library Media — National & World · National Desk
Dublin Closed, the Abuse Did Not: 185-Plus Accusations Against Officers in Federal Women’s Prisons, Five Years After the ‘Rape Club’
By Eleanor Ever Loyal
More than 185 cases of officers accused of sexually abusing people held in federal women’s prisons have emerged over a five-year period, according to a joint investigation by ProPublica and The Marshall Project published November 17. The findings indicate that the abuse allegations extended well beyond the California prison whose scandal became known as the “rape club,” despite federal officials’ promises of reform.
The investigation counted 172 women and 15 transgender men who accused officers of sexual abuse, using the publications’ stated methodology. The cases involved most of the 27 federal facilities that held women during the period and implicated at least 96 officers at 16 prisons. Only 19 of the officers were arrested or convicted, the investigation found. Those categories are distinct: an arrest is not a conviction, and an accusation does not establish guilt.
The investigation also identified more than 25 women who said they were abused by officers who had previously been reported or investigated. That pattern raises questions about whether the Bureau of Prisons acted effectively on earlier warnings and whether its safeguards protected incarcerated people from repeat abuse.
Federal officials vowed to reform the system in 2021. But more than a dozen current and former employees told the investigators they had seen few or no meaningful improvements.
The most prominent scandal unfolded at Federal Correctional Institution Dublin in California, where the abuse became so notorious that the prison was called the “rape club.” Ten officers pleaded guilty or were convicted, making it the largest sexual-abuse scandal in Bureau of Prisons history.
Among them was former warden Ray Garcia, who was sentenced to nearly six years in prison. His attorney says Garcia maintains his innocence. Another officer was freed after two trials ended with hung juries.
Dublin closed in early 2024, and more than 600 women were transferred. But the closure did not end the allegations associated with the facility. The investigation found that at least 47 prisoners alleged abuse after 2021, even as the government claimed abuse at Dublin was “virtually non-existent.”
A consent decree followed in early 2025 and is scheduled to expire early next year. The government also agreed to a $116 million settlement covering the first 103 Dublin victims, while about 300 additional cases remain pending. The settlement is not an admission of liability or proof of every allegation.
Other cases described in the investigation illustrate the range of allegations and legal outcomes at facilities across the system.
At the federal prison in Aliceville, Alabama, officer Felix Wilder, 35, was charged with abusing seven women. Wilder has pleaded not guilty. The investigation also found that the facility received perfect marks in its Prison Rape Elimination Act audits during the period associated with Wilder.
At the Federal Medical Center Carswell in Texas, paramedic Preston Emert was removed from his position after 18 women accused him of abuse. He had not been charged as of November, and officials said he was still employed as a paramedic. His supervisor was arrested last month after admitting to having sex with an incarcerated woman. The supervisor had not entered a plea, according to the information provided in the investigation.
At the facility in Tallahassee, officer Lenton Hatten was sentenced to three months in prison. DNA evidence tied him to the crime. His case was among more than 10 claims from that facility in a single year.
The investigation found that the system for identifying and substantiating abuse allegations had significant limitations. As of 2022, fewer than 10% of allegations were substantiated, while more than 75% were classified as having insufficient evidence.
Prison facilities continued to pass PREA audits despite the allegations. The Texas medical facility received a flawless audit the year the FBI arrived. Aliceville received perfect marks during the period in which Wilder was accused of abuse.
Those results underscore a central concern raised by the investigation: passing an audit did not necessarily mean that incarcerated people were safe or that allegations were being effectively addressed.
Alix McLearen, the Bureau of Prisons’ first administrator for women and special populations, retired in 2024. Her assessment of the changes made since the reform promises was blunt: “Nothing has really changed.”
The Bureau of Prisons defended its approach. Spokesperson Randilee Giamusso said the agency maintained a “zero tolerance” policy and had adopted a revamped investigation policy. Giamusso declined to comment on pending litigation.
The investigation also found that a federal oversight measure intended to strengthen accountability has not been put into operation. The Federal Prison Oversight Act’s ombuds office still does not exist, two years after the law’s passage, because Congress has not appropriated the funding needed to establish it.
The Justice Department also had not released the budget and progress report that both chambers of Congress directed it to provide by April.
The cases span multiple facilities, involve allegations at different stages of investigation and prosecution, and include both guilty pleas and convictions as well as accusations that have not resulted in charges. The distinction matters, particularly in cases still moving through the legal system. But the investigation’s broader finding is that allegations continued across the federal women’s prison system after officials promised reform, and that existing oversight measures did not prevent that pattern from continuing.
Dublin is closed. The pending cases, unresolved allegations and questions about institutional accountability remain.
Eleanor Ever Loyal
Lead Counsel & National Desk, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us
