Costa Rica’s Constitutional Chamber Strikes Judiciary Conditions and University-Fund Cut From 2027 Budget Bill

The Library Media — World

Costa Rica’s Constitutional Chamber Strikes Judiciary Conditions and University-Fund Cut From 2027 Budget Bill

By Maya Wilson

Share

Published November 20, 2026 · 2:48 PM PT

Costa Rica’s Constitutional Chamber, the Sala Constitucional, ruled on Friday, November 20, 2026, that five provisions of the 2027 national budget bill must be removed, in two decisions arising from constitutional consultations on the bill, legislative file 25.754.

In sentences 2026-045630 and 2026-045631, reported by Delfino.cr from the Chamber’s own communicated rulings, the Chamber found substantial procedural defects in the provisions and ordered them eliminated from the bill. If the Legislative Assembly does not eliminate them, they are deemed excluded from the budget law. The Chamber did not annul the budget as a whole.

The record made public on Friday is thin in important respects. The full texts of the sentences have not been published, and no vote tally was included in the rulings as communicated. This article reports only what the communicated rulings establish.

In ruling 2026-045630, on a consultation brought by the Supreme Court, the Chamber held that norms 9, 10, 11 and 12 of article 7 are unconstitutional.

Norma 9 conditioned the judiciary’s use of 29,843,810,438 colones — 5.6% of the Poder Judicial’s 2027 resources — on requirements including audited financial statements of a real-estate trust, certifications from the Contraloría General de la República, and sign-off by a legislative commission, the plenary and the Finance Ministry to release the funds. The affected spending included technology, infrastructure, rent, utilities, maintenance and equipment, reaching the judicial investigation agency, the OIJ.

Norma 10 barred certain internal transfers between budget lines through ordinary administrative channels, forcing them into extraordinary budgets before the Assembly.

Norma 12 conditioned the use of vacant posts on a Contraloría cost-benefit study, consideration by the full Supreme Court and approval by a legislative commission. The judiciary had warned it could affect 2,463 posts that appear vacant but are filled by interim staff, including prosecutors and investigators.

The content of norma 11 was not described in the ruling summary released Friday.

The Chamber’s grounds were that the norms were incorporated without the procedures in Articles 167 and 177 of the Constitution. Article 167 requires consulting the Supreme Court on bills affecting the judiciary’s organization or functioning, and a two-thirds vote of deputies — 38 — to depart from its view. The Chamber held that the special budget procedure had been used to introduce norms belonging to ordinary legislation. The ruling does not change the amounts assigned to the judiciary.

In ruling 2026-045631, on a consultation brought by deputies of the Frente Amplio and the Partido Liberación Nacional, the Chamber held unconstitutional the approval of motion No. 16 in the Assembly’s finance committee, which cut 8,048,128,252 colones from the FEES fund for public higher education and moved the money within the Education Ministry to finance employer contributions to the teachers’ pension board, Jupema.

The Chamber held the cut unconstitutional under Article 85. The FEES resources are agreed between the Executive and the public universities and cannot be modified unilaterally without a disagreement between the parties under that article’s procedure. If the Assembly does not correct it, the motion is deemed excluded and the earlier distribution is restored, so the 8,048 million colones remain with the universities.

The funds were part of university transfers postponed in 2020–2021 during the pandemic, which the government and universities agreed on November 20, 2025 to return gradually in eight annual payments. The Chamber did not rule on the whole university budget. Magistrate Luis Fernando Salazar Alvarado filed additional reasons saying the Chamber should also have examined whether the universities had to be consulted, under Article 88.

Several magistrates filed separate notes or reasons, whose full texts were not released: Fernando Cruz Castro and Salazar Alvarado jointly in the judiciary case; Fernando Castillo Víquez, Salazar Alvarado and Paul Rueda Leal with particular reasons; and Rueda Leal a separate note in the FEES case.

The Assembly must eliminate the four norms and correct the motion before definitively approving the budget. The Constitution requires the ordinary budget to be approved before November 30. The rulings were ordered communicated to the Assembly’s governing board.

The budget bill passed its first debate on November 5, with 31 votes of the governing Partido Pueblo Soberano in favor and 23 against. On November 9, two precautionary measures — one issued by Magistrate Fernando Cruz Castro as the Chamber’s interim president, one by Magistrate Ingrid Hess Herrera — froze the second debate while the consultations were decided. The Finance and Presidency minister, Rodrigo Chaves Robles, accused the Chamber of a “dictadura judicial” — “judicial dictatorship” — over those suspensions.

That accusation was a reaction to the November 9 suspensions, not to Friday’s rulings. No reaction from President Laura Fernández’s government or the bill’s sponsors to Friday’s rulings themselves was reported in the source. A third consultation, by PLN deputies on the same four judiciary norms, remains pending.

Maya Wilson

World Desk Lead, The Library Media

From The Library — the estate of our family.

Follow Us

X Facebook Instagram Threads Mastodon Bluesky

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top