French Parliament Adopts Police Shootings Law Presuming Officers Acted Lawfully; Critics Call It a ‘Licence to Kill’

The Library Media — World

French Parliament Adopts Police Shootings Law Presuming Officers Acted Lawfully; Critics Call It a ‘Licence to Kill’

By Maya Wilson

Share

Published November 20, 2026 · 2:33 PM PT

France’s parliament adopted a controversial law on Friday, November 20, establishing a presumption that police officers and gendarmes who use their weapons have acted within the framework of the law. Supporters say the measure provides legal protection for officers working in dangerous conditions, while critics warn it could make investigations into police shootings and accountability more difficult.

The Senate approved the legislation by 205 votes to 110 on Friday. The National Assembly, parliament’s lower house, had approved the text in July. Neither France 24 nor Reuters reported the July vote count or identified the bill’s author.

Under the new measure, officers who use their weapons are presumed to have acted lawfully unless evidence establishes otherwise. Reuters described the change as giving an officer who kills someone by shooting the benefit of the doubt unless there is proof to the contrary.

The government and the party of far-right presidential candidate Marine Le Pen backed the legislation. Reuters described it as a long-standing demand of far-right politicians.

Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez called it “an important measure to protect officers who work in dangerous conditions.” He also said it would “correct this reflex of systematically calling into question the daily, highly demanding work of our security forces,” according to France 24.

Conservative senator Lauriane Josende of The Republicans party, who opened the Senate debate on Thursday, said: “The aim is to provide law enforcement with legal protection tailored to the specific conditions in which they are required to intervene.” She argued that officers would no longer automatically be taken into custody for questioning after using their weapons or automatically suspected of disproportionate force.

Opponents say the presumption risks weakening scrutiny of police shootings. Activists have called the measure a “licence to kill.” France 24 reported concerns that it could hamper the opening of investigations and make it harder to hold security forces accountable, in a country where alleged police brutality cases rarely reach criminal court.

France’s Human Rights League has argued that the measure could prevent investigations from being opened after police shootings following a failure to comply at a traffic stop or during crowd control at protests.

Morris Tidball-Binz, the UN special rapporteur on extrajudicial executions, expressed concern before the Senate vote that the law could fuel impunity. “It should not fall on victims and their families to find the necessary elements to eliminate an initial presumption of lawfulness,” he wrote, particularly when authorities control key evidence.

Samia El Khalfaoui, an activist whose nephew Soheil was killed by a police officer in 2021, protested outside the Senate on Thursday. “The quest for truth will become even more impossible,” she said.

The adoption follows renewed attention to alleged police brutality during student-led protests in recent weeks. Demonstrators also marched in Paris against the bill on September 20. France 24 cited a report by the country’s rights chief last year finding that young men perceived as Arab, Black or from North Africa were four times more likely to be stopped than other people. Reuters also noted that the 2023 killing of 17-year-old Nahel Merzouk sparked nationwide riots.

The left has pledged to appeal to the Constitutional Council, France’s highest constitutional authority, in an effort to halt the legislation from coming into law. Neither report specifies a promulgation date or when the measure will take effect.

Maya Wilson

World Desk Lead, The Library Media

From The Library — the estate of our family.

Follow Us

X Facebook Instagram Threads Mastodon Bluesky

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top