
The Library Media — National & World · National Desk
Judge Allows Trump’s $15 Billion Defamation Case Against The New York Times to Proceed, in Part
By Eleanor Ever Loyal
A federal judge on Thursday allowed parts of President Donald Trump’s $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times, several of its journalists and publisher Penguin Random House to proceed, while dismissing other claims.
The ruling by U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday in Tampa, Florida, is a procedural decision about whether the allegations are legally sufficient to continue. It does not find that any statement was false or defamatory. Trump, as a public figure, must ultimately prove that the challenged statements were false and made with actual malice.
Merryday said Trump’s complaint plausibly alleged that statements in a Times article by journalist Peter Baker and in the book Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father’s Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success, by Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner, accusing Trump of “planning and perpetrating complex crimes” were “based on incomplete, minimal information.”
The judge dismissed Trump’s claims concerning a Times article about his work on the reality television show The Apprentice.
According to Law Commentary’s account of the ruling, the decision divided the claims: two of the lawsuit’s six counts were dismissed, while 27 challenged statements were found unable to support claims. Four counts involving seven statements were allowed to proceed. Six of those seven statements appeared in Lucky Loser, with the remaining statement in Baker’s October 2024 article, “For Trump, a Lifetime of Scandals Heads Toward a Moment of Judgment.”
Trump is seeking at least $15 billion in damages. His lawsuit, filed in September 2025, names The New York Times Company, Craig, Buettner, Baker and Penguin Random House. It challenges the book and two Times articles, which Trump says contained “false, malicious, defamatory, and disparaging” statements intended to sabotage his chances in the 2024 presidential election, which he won.
The disputed material questioned Trump’s account of his success as a businessman. His complaint cited more than two dozen statements concerning his role in creating The Apprentice, his inheritance from his father, his business ventures and his upbringing in New York City.
Merryday had previously dismissed an earlier version of the complaint without prejudice because its 85-page filing did not comply with federal pleading rules requiring a short and plain statement of the claim.
The Times and Penguin Random House have denied defaming Trump. In a court filing, they argued that the case was legally flawed and aimed at scoring political points. Their motion to dismiss said the complaint failed to explain how the statements were defamatory and included subjective opinions that could not be proven true or false.
A Times spokesman said the lawsuit had no legal merit and called it “a baseless attack on The Times and the rights of the free and independent press in this country.”
A spokesman for Trump’s personal legal team praised Thursday’s decision, saying the defendants “will now have to answer for intentionally and maliciously defaming President Trump.”
A Penguin Random House spokesperson said the publisher stood by the book and its authors and was confident the case would be fully dismissed.
Trump has filed several lawsuits against media companies since 2024. His critics have denounced the suits as attacks on the free press. Thursday’s ruling came a week after another federal judge allowed Trump’s defamation lawsuit against the BBC over a misleadingly edited clip to proceed. The BBC has denied liability.
The ruling does not establish a trial date, discovery schedule or next hearing.
Eleanor Ever Loyal
Lead Counsel & National Desk, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us