
The Library Media — World
Argentina’s Supreme Court Strikes Down Milei Decree Articles That Freed Private Health-Plan Fees
By Maya Wilson
Argentina’s Supreme Court declared unconstitutional two articles of President Javier Milei’s Decree of Necessity and Urgency 70/2023 that had deregulated fees charged by private health-plan companies, restoring the enforcement authority’s supervisory and authorisation responsibilities under the country’s prepaga law. The ruling does not impose a cap tying increases to the Consumer Price Index (IPC).
The articles, 267 and 269, had removed two central protections under Law 26.682: the enforcement authority’s power to review health-plan fees and changes to them, and the State’s obligation to supervise and guarantee that prices were reasonable. Under the previous system, increases had to reflect variations in companies’ cost structures and a reasonable actuarial calculation of risk, and required authorisation by the enforcement authority. After the decree, companies were free to set their fees.
The Court ordered the enforcement authority to resume its supervisory and authorisation functions under the prepaga law. It confirmed the declaration that the two articles were unconstitutional but only partially upheld the lower court’s judgment, revoking the remainder, including the La Plata appeals chamber’s order limiting increases to the IPC. The court of origin must issue a new decision in accordance with the Supreme Court’s criteria. The ruling therefore does not establish an IPC-based ceiling on health-plan increases.
The case began when an individual plan member identified as “MB” filed an amparo action against Swiss Medical SA. Her monthly fee rose 110% between December 2023 and February 2024, from 136,161.21 pesos to 301,218.02 pesos. She argued that under the previous regulatory system, the January 2024 increase would have been 6.26%. The amparo was initially rejected, but Sala II of the Federal Appeals Chamber of La Plata reversed that decision, declared the decree articles unconstitutional and imposed the IPC limit. Swiss Medical and the national state both appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court based its decision on the constitutional limits governing the Executive’s decree-making power. It said a decree of necessity and urgency is permitted only under conditions of rigorous exceptionality: when circumstances prevent the ordinary legislative process or when urgency is incompatible with the time required to pass a law.
The Court held that the Executive had not demonstrated those circumstances. It found that the decree’s recitals provided not even a minimal justification for changing Law 26.682 and did not attempt to establish a concrete connection between the invoked economic and social emergency and the need to eliminate the State’s powers of control. The Court said considerations of mere convenience for the Executive must be ruled out, and that the Constitution does not permit the government to choose at its discretion between passing legislation and more quickly imposing substantive rules by decree.
The Court also clarified that its decision was confined to articles 267 and 269 and did not express a view on the constitutionality of the remainder of DNU 70/2023. The reported account does not state whether the ruling applies generally or only to the parties in the case.
The vote count and the names of the justices were not reported. No reaction was reported from the Milei administration, the Health Ministry, Swiss Medical, the private health-plan companies’ chamber or consumer groups. The account also provides no implementation timeline for the enforcement authority’s return to its supervisory and authorisation functions.
Maya Wilson
World Desk Lead, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us