
The Library Media — World
Israel Is Denying Some Americans Entry Under the Visa Waiver Program, a Former US Official Warns
By Maya Wilson
Photo: PESP/ Wikimedia / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Israel is increasingly denying entry to some US citizens arriving in the country, including Palestinian Americans, and redirecting some travellers to enter through Jordan, according to an analysis by former US official Hady Amr published in Lawfare on November 18. Amr argues that the reported practices may violate the terms under which Israel joined the US Visa Waiver Program, but says a systematic pattern would need to be established before Washington considers enforcement measures.
Amr, a nonresident senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and an associate fellow at Chatham House, wrote that reports of Americans being refused entry at Tel Aviv’s Ben Gurion Airport appeared to have become more frequent and systematic since some time after President Donald Trump took office. He said the system had appeared to work reasonably well through 2024.
As evidence, Amr cited at least a dozen cases he said he had personally heard about in recent months and discussed with the Americans involved, as well as paper entry tickets he had seen. His article did not name the individuals involved or provide dates for the cases.
Amr described a pattern in which Palestinian Americans arriving at Ben Gurion Airport were allegedly refused entry and told to enter through the Allenby Bridge from Jordan. Those entering through Allenby, he wrote, were often given small paper tickets restricting their permission to the West Bank or limiting their stay to a few weeks. He said the restrictions were recorded on the tickets rather than stamped in passports.
He also reported cases involving Americans who were apparently denied entry because of their political views, including an interfaith group led by a retired Emory University professor and members of a comedy group. Neither group was named or dated in the analysis.
Amr further wrote that Israeli Diaspora Minister Amichai Chikli had boasted in February that Israel would bar individuals or groups it did not like regardless of their background. That characterisation is Amr’s account; his article did not provide a verbatim quotation from Chikli.
The dispute concerns the terms of Israel’s participation in the Visa Waiver Program, established in 1986 and covering 42 countries. The programme allows reciprocal visa-free travel for stays of up to 90 days. Israel was admitted in the summer of 2023 after signing a memorandum of understanding with the United States on July 19 that set out equal-treatment requirements for US citizens at Israeli-controlled ports of entry.
Under the agreement, all US citizens, including Palestinian Americans and people listed in the Palestinian population registry, were to be treated equally regardless of national origin, religion or ethnicity. They were to be able to enter through Ben Gurion and other Israeli-controlled ports under the same standards applied to other Americans.
The memorandum specifically states that “[a]ny U.S. citizen who is on the Palestinian population registry for Gaza, including a resident of Gaza, and is located outside of Gaza, will be able to seek to enter Israel visa-free through Israeli international ports of entry.”
The agreement does not prohibit all refusals of entry. It permits denials on legitimate security, criminal, health or immigration grounds, provided those standards are applied uniformly. It does not permit ethnic background or other immutable characteristics to be used as a proxy for those grounds.
The memorandum is nonbinding, but reciprocity is a requirement of US law. In 2023, the State Department said: “All U.S. citizens traveling to Israel with a valid U.S. passport are to be recognized by Israel as U.S. citizens and receive equal treatment without regard to race, religion, or national origin.” American diplomats during the candidacy used the phrase “Blue means blue!” to express the principle.
Amr argues that redirecting Palestinian American travellers from Ben Gurion to the Allenby crossing is squarely inconsistent with the agreement. He says that if the reported denials prove systematic, the United States has both precedent and an obligation to enforce the terms of the bargain.
He also argues that the Trump administration’s lack of public reporting has left Americans without a full picture of how widespread the problem may be. According to Amr, responses by US officials to individual reports have been limited to modest acknowledgments and suggestions that the affected person contact a lawyer.
Amr proposes that Washington first conduct a rigorous assessment and share its findings with the public or at least Congress. Depending on what documented violations establish, he says possible measures could include placing Israel on provisional status, shortening the validity of travel authorizations, suspending its participation or terminating it from the programme.
He cites previous actions against other participating countries: Argentina was removed in 2002 and Uruguay in 2003; Belgium was placed on provisional status in 2003; and Hungary was placed on provisional status in 2017, with travel authorizations for its citizens limited in 2023.
The evidence presented in Amr’s article does not establish the scale of the alleged practice. It contains no official statistics on entry denials, no named cases and no response from the Israeli government to the claims. It also provides no current US assessment of Israel’s compliance with the memorandum.
Amr’s conclusion is conditional on equal treatment not being ensured. He writes: “If Israel cannot ensure equal treatment for all American travelers—including Palestinian Americans—Washington should enforce the bargain it made.”
Maya Wilson
World Desk Lead, The Library Media
From The Library — the estate of our family.
Follow Us
