The Bombs Are the Opening Statement

Punching Down

Follow The Library Media

FacebookXThreadsInstagramBlueskyTelegramMastodonMedium

The Library Media — Opinion & Investigations · Editorial

The Bombs Are the Opening Statement

By Catalina Clarke

Published November 10, 2026 · 8:24 PM PT

Catalina Clarke

Catalina Clarke

Editor-in-Chief of The Library Media.

There is a word diplomacy cannot do without, and it is being spent carelessly in Abu Dhabi this week: good faith.

On Tuesday, delegations sat down in Abu Dhabi for U.S.-brokered talks on the war in Ukraine — the invader at the table, the broker beside it, and the invaded country asked to treat the seating plan as progress. In the same hours, Russian strikes were falling on Ukrainian cities. Our own news desk’s Tuesday file reads like a metronome: Sumy. A passenger train at Sumy. Ladyzhyn. The country’s energy grid. Zaporizhzhia. Nizhyn and Donetsk. Dnipro and Kramatorsk.

That is not a negotiating position. That is a threat with a briefing paper attached.

Good faith is not a mood, and it is not a press line. It has a plain meaning that every negotiator in every field understands: you do not improve your terms by injuring the other side while the talks are open. A party that bombs apartment blocks and passenger trains in the hours around a session is telling you, in the clearest language available to it, what it believes the talks are for. They are for ratifying what the bombs are trying to take.

Ukraine is being asked to accept a format in which its cities are the leverage. Sit down, the arrangement says, and understand that every hour you decline the terms on offer, the terms are being written elsewhere — in the sky over Sumy, over Dnipro, over Kramatorsk. A negotiation conducted that way is not a path to peace. It is a surrender ceremony stretched over several days, with better catering.

It is worth saying plainly who benefits from calling this diplomacy. Russia gains time, legitimacy, and a photograph: its delegation seated as a coequal power beside the United States, dictating conditions to the country it invaded — as though the invasion were a dispute between neighbors rather than a war of conquest against a sovereign state whose civilians it killed this morning. The broker gains the appearance of dealmaking. Ukraine gains the bill.

None of this is an argument against talks. Wars end at tables; this one will too. It is an argument about sequence, and sequence is where good faith lives. A ceasefire first — real, monitored, and costly to break. Then talks, in which the side that has stopped killing is not rewarded for pausing, and the side that was attacked is not punished for surviving. Then terms that a free country could accept without teaching every watching aggressor that invasion plus patience equals annexation.

Until the bombs stop, the Abu Dhabi table offers Ukraine nothing of value, and asking Kyiv to pretend otherwise is not statesmanship. It is an insult with a flag on it.

Russia knows what good faith would look like. So does Washington. The people of Sumy, who buried their neighbors while the delegations were taking their seats, know it best of all.

— Catalina Clarke, Editor-in-Chief
From The Library — the estate of our family.

X Facebook Instagram Threads Mastodon Bluesky

Share

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top