The Library Media — National & World · World Desk
By Maya Wilson
Follow The Library Media
Gaza authorities slam global ‘inaction’ after mudslide kills five people
Gaza City — A sandbank collapsed onto a tent in Deir el-Balah on Sunday, killing five people, after heavy rain from the first winter storm of the year, according to Al Jazeera.
Al Jazeera reported that four children and a woman were killed, and that two people were still missing.
The BBC reported a different toll on Monday morning: four people killed, three children and one woman, citing the Hamas-run health ministry. The BBC noted that Civil Defence had initially reported three children and two women killed on Sunday.
The discrepancy is not a rounding error or a minor update. It reflects the difficulty of counting the dead in a place where the systems for doing so are under strain and where information moves unevenly between agencies, journalists and the public.
About 70,000 tents were flooded when the storm hit at the weekend, according to both Al Jazeera and the BBC. The figure captures the scale of exposure in Gaza, where displaced families are living in temporary shelter at the start of winter.
Civil Defence said water reached up to 1.5 metres in places. Responders were able to answer only 10 per cent of the 2,100 distress calls they received, according to the BBC.
Gaza’s Government Media Office said on Monday that the scene “should shame the conscience of humanity” and held Israel, the United States and the international community responsible. Al Jazeera attributed the statement to the office.
Data from Save the Children cited by Al Jazeera put more than half a million children in “critical or catastrophic” shelter conditions. Karl Baker of the International Organization for Migration told the BBC that Gaza’s 2.1 million people are confined to 30 per cent of its area.
The mudslide was not an isolated incident. It was the fatal consequence of a storm that overwhelmed shelters already weakened by months of displacement and damage, in a territory where space, materials and services are severely limited.
The storm arrived at a time when Gaza’s population is concentrated in a reduced area, with families relying on tents and other temporary structures. Flooding on the scale reported — 70,000 tents affected — does not merely damage property. It exposes people to cold, disease and further displacement.
The death toll, however it is finally counted, is small in comparison with the numbers at risk. More than half a million children are in shelter conditions described as critical or catastrophic. The question raised by the storm is not only how many people died in a single tent in Deir el-Balah, but how many more are living in conditions that make such deaths likely.
For now, the immediate facts are these: a sandbank collapsed after heavy rain; five people were killed, according to Al Jazeera, or four, according to the BBC’s Monday-morning figure from the health ministry; two people were still missing, according to Al Jazeera; and tens of thousands of tents were flooded.
The longer question is whether the winter will bring a repeat of the same pattern: a storm, a collapse, a contested count, and a statement of condemnation. The authorities in Gaza have said the scene should shame the conscience of humanity. The test will be whether that shame translates into shelter, space and protection before the next storm.
(Maya Wilson — Intelligence Lead, The Library Media)
From The Library — the estate of our family.